IICP HSE Academy
QHSE Management

QHSE Benchmarking: Comparing Performance to Improve

QHSE benchmarking compares practices and indicators with top organizations. A powerful management tool, it drives continuous improvement under ISO 9001/14001/45001.

IICP HSE Academy Published on 18 October 2026 5 min read 8 views
Benchmarking QHSE — Comparer et s'améliorer

Benchmarking QHSE: Comparing Performance to Improve

QHSE benchmarking consists of comparing one's practices and indicators with those of leading organizations. A powerful management tool, it fuels continuous improvement according to ISO 9001/14001/45001.

QHSE benchmarking consists of comparing one's practices and indicators with those of leading organizations, internal or external, to identify areas for improvement. A powerful management tool, it fuels continuous improvement as required by the ISO 9001:2015, ISO 14001:2015 and ISO 45001:2018 standards.

Definition

Benchmarking is a systematic comparison of products, services, processes, or performance with those of organizations recognized as leaders. It is not about copying, but about understanding the success factors and adapting them to one's own context.

Types of Benchmarking

Four main types:

  1. Internal: Comparison between sites, departments, or subsidiaries of the same company.
  2. Competitive: Comparison with direct competitors in the same sector.
  3. Functional: Comparison of similar functions (HR, maintenance, safety) between companies in different sectors.
  4. Generic: Comparison of generic processes (project management, order taking) with global best practices.

Process

The approach follows a structured cycle:

  1. Identify what is being compared: process, indicator, practice.
  2. Select benchmarking partners.
  3. Collect data: visits, interviews, quantitative indicators, documents.
  4. Analyze gaps: performance, practices, success conditions.
  5. Define an action plan: objectives, deadlines, resources, follow-up indicators.
  6. Implement and sustain: follow-up, review, integration into the QHSE management system.

QHSE Indicators Compared

The main QHSE indicators compared are:

  • Frequency Rate (FR): number of lost-time accidents per million hours worked.
  • Severity Rate (SR): number of lost days per thousand hours worked.
  • Cost of accidents (direct + indirect costs).
  • Regulatory compliance rate.
  • Incident rate (near misses).
  • Environmental footprint (CO2, water, waste, energy).
  • Training rate and participation rate in QHSE initiatives.

Benefits

Benchmarking provides:

  • Identification of concrete areas for improvement.
  • Setting realistic and ambitious objectives (based on the leader).
  • Highlighting transferable best practices.
  • Mobilization of teams around a progress project.
  • Strengthening the QHSE culture.

Link with ISO 9001/14001/45001

The ISO 9001:2015, ISO 14001:2015, and ISO 45001:2018 standards require analysis (Chapter 9.1 — monitoring, measurement, analysis, and evaluation) and improvement (Chapter 10). Benchmarking is a tool for performance analysis and identifying improvement opportunities.

Sources et références

  1. Code du travail marocain (Loi n° 65-99), Titre IV — articles 281 et suivants ILO NATLEX : https://natlex.ilo.org/dyn/natlex2/r/natlex/fe/details?p3_isn=67319

  2. INRS — Démarche QHSE (portail risques) https://www.inrs.fr/risques.html

  3. OSHA — Safety Pays (programme US de calcul des coûts d'accidents) https://www.osha.gov/safety-pays

Share
Back to blog